LtspSshXdmcpLocaldev
Please check the status of this specification in Launchpad before editing it. If it is Approved, contact the Assignee or another knowledgeable person before making changes.
Launchpad Entry: ltsp-ssh-xdmcp-localdev
Packages affected: ltsp-client, ltsp-server
Summary
Currently, Local device connections are plumbed via an ssh command channel. This works fine, until we switch to using XDMCP, when it breaks. We need to come up with a common command channel that will work in both instances.
Rationale
XDMCP, while insecure, is much faster than tunelling X over SSH. For low powered thin clients, it may be desirable to switch to XDMCP as a communications method.
Use Cases
- Ollie has just been asked to set up an Edubuntu lab in a developing nation by his boss. On arriving, he finds that all the machines are Pentium 90's with 64 megs of RAM. Running the standard LTSP encrypted setup isn't an option, as the clients just don't have enough power. They work fine as XDMCP, though.
- Scott wants to do video on his thin client. He's got a gigabit network, but tunelling over SSH introduces too much latency. He's not worried about security on his local network.
Scope
ltsp-server
Design
Thin Client
Review: this dection does have a fair amount of poorly-separated Implementation content.
- Well defined place for Xorg's .Xauth file to be written (in /tmp, but not named /tmp/fileKJHDJ)
- Bind mount /root/.Xauthority
- Logging in, and staticdev detection handled with:
while /bin/true; do
FSTAB=$(cat /etc/fstab)
while [ ! $(xprop -root -f LTSP_FSTAB 8s -set LTSP_FSTAB "${FSTAB}" > /dev/null) ]; do
sleep 2
done
xblock # discussed later
done- This will wait until the X server is up, then set the X property LTSP_FSTAB on the root window.
- This property will survive past an LDM or XDMCP login, but after a logout, an xreset is done. All clients are disconnected, and all properties are cleared.
- We'll need a small program, called xblock.
- Does a connect to the X server, sits in empty event loop.
- Simply exits quietly on X disconnect.
add-fstab-entry now simply:
- updates the /etc/fstab file
- updates the LTSP_FSTAB xprop (if X isn't up yet, not a problem, fail quietly, and the above bit of code will handle this automatically).
eliminate the static-mounter daemon.
fix cdpinger to set the xprop.
Host Server
Need to create a daemon that is started from /etc/X11/Xsession.d
- Looks at initial LTSP_FSTAB xprop, mounts anything not already there.
- Listens for changes in the xproperty during the session
- mounts and unmounts media accordingly
- on session exit, cleans up all mounts before exiting.
Implementation
- Thin client side already done, and mostly tested.
- Need to design server side:
- Should it tie into dbus?
What will be the impact of ltspfs-virtual-hal-devices ?
Need to coordinate with VagrantCascadian and OliverGrawert
Review:Those open questions need to be answered (if critical), or moved to Outstanding Issues
Outstanding Issues